“You can’t solve something like this with a .45,” Granny says. “It’s not as simple as one person – it’s the whole system, son.”
“Tell us what you mean, Granny.”
Journalist Ben Manalowitz, BJ Novak’s character in his movie Vengeance, is investigating the death of a small-town girl named Abilene Shaw.
With their Southern hospitality, the Shaws invite Ben to dinner.
Classic fish-out-of-water conflict: A city boy from New York who isn’t used to getting his hands dirty is caught in a dusty town full of people who protect their loved ones by any means necessary.
Ben pushes his recorder closer to Granny and urges her to continue, mistaking her passion for pacifism.
“It’s the breakdown of society is what it is,” Granny says. “It’s the breakdown of the school system, the government. It’s the pharmaceutical companies. It’s the breakdown of the family and tradition. Ooh, there’s a whole lot of people responsible for what happened to Abilene⦠You’re gonna need a 12-gauge, a couple ARs, a Wesson automatic and a sidearm for safety.“
“We’re not doing that,” Ben says.
“Oh, we’re not?” Granny scoffs. “Yeah. I didn’t think you had the balls.”
The Shaw family wants retribution. Ben then pleads his case – using very big words – that the pen is in fact mightier than the sword.
“There’s some things I’m good at. I’m good at asking the right questions. I’m good at getting people to talk. And I’m especially good at drawing thematic connections between seemingly disparate elements and using that to illustrate a larger point or theory.
“So, whoever – or whatever – is responsible for what happened to Abilene, I will find this person or this generalized societal force, and I will define it.
“I’ll define it.“
“Bless your heart,” mama Shaw says.
It’s that last “I’ll define it” that always gets me.
As if Ben needed to convince himself that defining an issue is enough. That a journalist’s role in reporting on a murder is justified in their singular outcome. That justice is handed out by calling out the injustice.
When Granny is calling into question your cajones, it makes you wonder what you’re really accomplishing.
I watched this movie almost three years ago. I think about Ben’s quote nearly every day.
My pen is uncapped, scribbling anything that begs for examination.
My sword is sheathed, hid away under the bed.
May my heart be forever blessed.


